User login
For decades I have suspected that there is a strong association between sleep deprivation and pediatric attention disorders. More recently I have wondered whether screen time, particularly at bedtime might be a significant contributor to sleep quantity and quality in both children and adults. There is a growing body of research that combines my two observations and suggests that bedtime screen time through its effect on sleep may be linked to pediatric attention problems. However, most of this work is preliminary and needs to be confirmed.
Stumbling across a paper from England titled “Toddler Screen Use Before Bed and Its Effect on Sleep and Attention” renewed my hope that we finally have evidence to close that knowledge gap. My bubble burst quickly however when I jumped ahead and read the conclusion portion of the abstract and learned that authors observed “no clear difference in parent reported attention” in the group of children in which screen time before bedtime had been eliminated. The authors wonder if their small study sample may be to blame.
Disappointed, I persisted and read the paper in its entirety and found that despite their failure to link bedtime screen time with attention disorders, the investigators have made a significant contribution to our understanding of how we can better encourage good pediatric sleep hygiene.
The Study
One hundred and five families with a toddler who was being exposed to a video screen in the hour before bedtime were divided into three groups. One group received guidance and advice from a pediatric team about the potential benefit of eliminating bedtime screen time. They were also given a box of activities that contained “activity cards and age appropriate toys” to replace the screen use. The family also received periodic support and follow-up contacts. A second group received only the “bedtime box.” And the third received no intervention.
It is important to note that the investigators modeled their intervention on one developed in a previous study using older children that was “co-created with caregivers and early years practitioners”(my italics).
The intervention resulted in reductions in parent-reported screen time, sleep efficiency, night awakenings, and daytime sleep. The decrease in nap time was a surprise to the investigators.
These reductions were small. However, the investigators were most impressed (and I share in their sentiment) with the finding that 99% (104/105) of the families stayed with the study until completion, demonstrating that future studies using this format were highly feasible. The authors of the study were pleased also and possibly surprised that 94% (33/35) of the families who received the intervention adhered to the recommendations.
One Suggestion: ‘Just Shut the TV Off’
If you are a cynic, you might be tempted to explain the investigators’ (and my) excitement over the feasibility and adherence numbers as an attempt to pump up the importance of a set of otherwise lackluster numbers regarding sleep and the failure to find any association between the intervention and attention. However, having spent a large part of my career trying to encourage parents to improve their child’s sleep hygiene, often with little success, I am encouraged by this study’s success in getting families to accept and then adhere to the intervention.
I must admit that when presented with a child who appeared to be having some attention difficulties and was watching television as part of his or her bedtime ritual, there’s a good chance I would have simply told the parents, “Just shut the TV off.” This certainly worked with some families, particularly those who had already bought into my preaching about the importance of sleep. However, my acceptance and adherence rates were no where near the 99% and 94% these investigators where achieving.
I did try to make follow-up phone calls, as these investigators did, but generally only to the most seriously effected families or in situations in which felt I was going to have the greatest chance of success. I am sorry to say that I didn’t involve the parents in crafting my overly simplistic intervention. Had I been more open to parental input, I suspect my results would have improved.
An Alternative
I think another reason for these investigators’ success was the clever ploy of offering a replacement (in this case the bedtime box of alternative activities) when they asked the parents to remove the screen time. Getting anyone to break an unhealthy habit, be they parents or patients, it often helps to offer them an alternative. The activity may not be as appealing as their current behavior but it can fill the gap until a new even healthier behavior develops.
Building an efficient and effective bedtime ritual begins in the first months of life. The initial challenge could be separating nursing or a bottle from the settling in process. Later on it could mean helping a parent who is out of the home all day understand that they may have to suppress their natural urge to engage in vigorous play with his/her child at a time that is best devoted to winding down into a healthy bedtime ritual. Although screen time may not be physically stimulating, there is increasing evidence that it shouldn’t be part of a pre-bedtime ritual. The question of if and how it contributes to attention problems will have to wait until another day.
Dr. Wilkoff practiced primary care pediatrics in Brunswick, Maine, for nearly 40 years. He has authored several books on behavioral pediatrics, including “How to Say No to Your Toddler.” Other than a Littman stethoscope he accepted as a first-year medical student in 1966, Dr. Wilkoff reports having nothing to disclose. Email him at pdnews@mdedge.com.
For decades I have suspected that there is a strong association between sleep deprivation and pediatric attention disorders. More recently I have wondered whether screen time, particularly at bedtime might be a significant contributor to sleep quantity and quality in both children and adults. There is a growing body of research that combines my two observations and suggests that bedtime screen time through its effect on sleep may be linked to pediatric attention problems. However, most of this work is preliminary and needs to be confirmed.
Stumbling across a paper from England titled “Toddler Screen Use Before Bed and Its Effect on Sleep and Attention” renewed my hope that we finally have evidence to close that knowledge gap. My bubble burst quickly however when I jumped ahead and read the conclusion portion of the abstract and learned that authors observed “no clear difference in parent reported attention” in the group of children in which screen time before bedtime had been eliminated. The authors wonder if their small study sample may be to blame.
Disappointed, I persisted and read the paper in its entirety and found that despite their failure to link bedtime screen time with attention disorders, the investigators have made a significant contribution to our understanding of how we can better encourage good pediatric sleep hygiene.
The Study
One hundred and five families with a toddler who was being exposed to a video screen in the hour before bedtime were divided into three groups. One group received guidance and advice from a pediatric team about the potential benefit of eliminating bedtime screen time. They were also given a box of activities that contained “activity cards and age appropriate toys” to replace the screen use. The family also received periodic support and follow-up contacts. A second group received only the “bedtime box.” And the third received no intervention.
It is important to note that the investigators modeled their intervention on one developed in a previous study using older children that was “co-created with caregivers and early years practitioners”(my italics).
The intervention resulted in reductions in parent-reported screen time, sleep efficiency, night awakenings, and daytime sleep. The decrease in nap time was a surprise to the investigators.
These reductions were small. However, the investigators were most impressed (and I share in their sentiment) with the finding that 99% (104/105) of the families stayed with the study until completion, demonstrating that future studies using this format were highly feasible. The authors of the study were pleased also and possibly surprised that 94% (33/35) of the families who received the intervention adhered to the recommendations.
One Suggestion: ‘Just Shut the TV Off’
If you are a cynic, you might be tempted to explain the investigators’ (and my) excitement over the feasibility and adherence numbers as an attempt to pump up the importance of a set of otherwise lackluster numbers regarding sleep and the failure to find any association between the intervention and attention. However, having spent a large part of my career trying to encourage parents to improve their child’s sleep hygiene, often with little success, I am encouraged by this study’s success in getting families to accept and then adhere to the intervention.
I must admit that when presented with a child who appeared to be having some attention difficulties and was watching television as part of his or her bedtime ritual, there’s a good chance I would have simply told the parents, “Just shut the TV off.” This certainly worked with some families, particularly those who had already bought into my preaching about the importance of sleep. However, my acceptance and adherence rates were no where near the 99% and 94% these investigators where achieving.
I did try to make follow-up phone calls, as these investigators did, but generally only to the most seriously effected families or in situations in which felt I was going to have the greatest chance of success. I am sorry to say that I didn’t involve the parents in crafting my overly simplistic intervention. Had I been more open to parental input, I suspect my results would have improved.
An Alternative
I think another reason for these investigators’ success was the clever ploy of offering a replacement (in this case the bedtime box of alternative activities) when they asked the parents to remove the screen time. Getting anyone to break an unhealthy habit, be they parents or patients, it often helps to offer them an alternative. The activity may not be as appealing as their current behavior but it can fill the gap until a new even healthier behavior develops.
Building an efficient and effective bedtime ritual begins in the first months of life. The initial challenge could be separating nursing or a bottle from the settling in process. Later on it could mean helping a parent who is out of the home all day understand that they may have to suppress their natural urge to engage in vigorous play with his/her child at a time that is best devoted to winding down into a healthy bedtime ritual. Although screen time may not be physically stimulating, there is increasing evidence that it shouldn’t be part of a pre-bedtime ritual. The question of if and how it contributes to attention problems will have to wait until another day.
Dr. Wilkoff practiced primary care pediatrics in Brunswick, Maine, for nearly 40 years. He has authored several books on behavioral pediatrics, including “How to Say No to Your Toddler.” Other than a Littman stethoscope he accepted as a first-year medical student in 1966, Dr. Wilkoff reports having nothing to disclose. Email him at pdnews@mdedge.com.
For decades I have suspected that there is a strong association between sleep deprivation and pediatric attention disorders. More recently I have wondered whether screen time, particularly at bedtime might be a significant contributor to sleep quantity and quality in both children and adults. There is a growing body of research that combines my two observations and suggests that bedtime screen time through its effect on sleep may be linked to pediatric attention problems. However, most of this work is preliminary and needs to be confirmed.
Stumbling across a paper from England titled “Toddler Screen Use Before Bed and Its Effect on Sleep and Attention” renewed my hope that we finally have evidence to close that knowledge gap. My bubble burst quickly however when I jumped ahead and read the conclusion portion of the abstract and learned that authors observed “no clear difference in parent reported attention” in the group of children in which screen time before bedtime had been eliminated. The authors wonder if their small study sample may be to blame.
Disappointed, I persisted and read the paper in its entirety and found that despite their failure to link bedtime screen time with attention disorders, the investigators have made a significant contribution to our understanding of how we can better encourage good pediatric sleep hygiene.
The Study
One hundred and five families with a toddler who was being exposed to a video screen in the hour before bedtime were divided into three groups. One group received guidance and advice from a pediatric team about the potential benefit of eliminating bedtime screen time. They were also given a box of activities that contained “activity cards and age appropriate toys” to replace the screen use. The family also received periodic support and follow-up contacts. A second group received only the “bedtime box.” And the third received no intervention.
It is important to note that the investigators modeled their intervention on one developed in a previous study using older children that was “co-created with caregivers and early years practitioners”(my italics).
The intervention resulted in reductions in parent-reported screen time, sleep efficiency, night awakenings, and daytime sleep. The decrease in nap time was a surprise to the investigators.
These reductions were small. However, the investigators were most impressed (and I share in their sentiment) with the finding that 99% (104/105) of the families stayed with the study until completion, demonstrating that future studies using this format were highly feasible. The authors of the study were pleased also and possibly surprised that 94% (33/35) of the families who received the intervention adhered to the recommendations.
One Suggestion: ‘Just Shut the TV Off’
If you are a cynic, you might be tempted to explain the investigators’ (and my) excitement over the feasibility and adherence numbers as an attempt to pump up the importance of a set of otherwise lackluster numbers regarding sleep and the failure to find any association between the intervention and attention. However, having spent a large part of my career trying to encourage parents to improve their child’s sleep hygiene, often with little success, I am encouraged by this study’s success in getting families to accept and then adhere to the intervention.
I must admit that when presented with a child who appeared to be having some attention difficulties and was watching television as part of his or her bedtime ritual, there’s a good chance I would have simply told the parents, “Just shut the TV off.” This certainly worked with some families, particularly those who had already bought into my preaching about the importance of sleep. However, my acceptance and adherence rates were no where near the 99% and 94% these investigators where achieving.
I did try to make follow-up phone calls, as these investigators did, but generally only to the most seriously effected families or in situations in which felt I was going to have the greatest chance of success. I am sorry to say that I didn’t involve the parents in crafting my overly simplistic intervention. Had I been more open to parental input, I suspect my results would have improved.
An Alternative
I think another reason for these investigators’ success was the clever ploy of offering a replacement (in this case the bedtime box of alternative activities) when they asked the parents to remove the screen time. Getting anyone to break an unhealthy habit, be they parents or patients, it often helps to offer them an alternative. The activity may not be as appealing as their current behavior but it can fill the gap until a new even healthier behavior develops.
Building an efficient and effective bedtime ritual begins in the first months of life. The initial challenge could be separating nursing or a bottle from the settling in process. Later on it could mean helping a parent who is out of the home all day understand that they may have to suppress their natural urge to engage in vigorous play with his/her child at a time that is best devoted to winding down into a healthy bedtime ritual. Although screen time may not be physically stimulating, there is increasing evidence that it shouldn’t be part of a pre-bedtime ritual. The question of if and how it contributes to attention problems will have to wait until another day.
Dr. Wilkoff practiced primary care pediatrics in Brunswick, Maine, for nearly 40 years. He has authored several books on behavioral pediatrics, including “How to Say No to Your Toddler.” Other than a Littman stethoscope he accepted as a first-year medical student in 1966, Dr. Wilkoff reports having nothing to disclose. Email him at pdnews@mdedge.com.